🧪 Research

Fintokei Expected Value and Is SwiftTrader Worth It? Two Simulations of Challenge vs. SwiftTrader: Challenge If You Risk the Maximum, SwiftTrader Only for 3+ Trades a Day at 0.5% or Less [November 2026]

Published: 9/27/2026Updated: 11/7/2026

📢 Advertising / affiliate disclosure: This article contains a prop-memo.com affiliate link (marked 🎁, for Fintokei). The simulation's assumptions and numbers are calculated under the same conditions regardless of any affiliate relationship.

※ Rules and pricing were confirmed on Fintokei's official site and official help center on September 27, 2026 (the comparison with FTMO and E8 Markets was checked on each firm's official site on September 20, 2026; only FTMO's prices are third-party data). Since Fintokei prices in yen, fees have been normalized to "a percentage of account size" and shown at the equivalent of a $100K account (for a ¥20M account, multiply the amounts in the tables by 200 to get yen). The simulations don't guarantee future results and are not investment advice.

※ On November 7, 2026, we merged "Is Fintokei's SwiftTrader Plan a Trap for the Unwary?" into this article.

Conclusion

  • If you take risk up to the rule limit, Challenge wins at every skill level. In the 120-trading-day calculation (3 trades a day) that includes SwiftTrader's 60-day limit, 3% daily profit cap during evaluation, and +3% per payout, each plan's best lot size against the other's gave 4.7x vs. 1.9x, 29x vs. 11.5x, 100x vs. 42x, and 203x vs. 93x.
  • SwiftTrader only wins for high-frequency methods that fire 3+ times a day and stack up 0.5% or less per trade. At the same 0.5%, SwiftTrader passes faster (13–20 days vs. 30–67) and pays a 90% split. Above 1% per trade, the fail rate per account hits 100%.
  • SwiftTrader's low price, speed, and 90% split are built by shrinking the bucket. Overall loss is 3% (Challenge: 10%), so the fee per ¥10,000 of loss allowance is ¥1,563 vs. ¥549 (2.85x). Target ÷ loss allowance is 2.0 (Challenge Phase 1: 0.8).
  • In the 1-year calculation, which rebuys after every fail, Challenge and SwiftTrader come out nearly even at 1% risk and "medium" edge (+$21,609 vs. +$21,285). SwiftTrader Diamond, with a 100% split, came out on top at +$23,739. But that calculation doesn't include the 60-day limit or the evaluation profit cap, so SwiftTrader's numbers look better than they would in reality.
  • With zero edge (50% win rate), Challenge is the least bad option at every lot size in the 1-year calculation. SwiftTrader's overall limit is only 3%, so you end up rebuying it many times a year.
  • On both plans, the Scaling Dojo's White Belt tier (20 trading days + 2 payouts) refunds a contract fee equal to what you paid.

Fintokei's plans (at $100K equivalent)

Challenge (ProTrader)SwiftTraderSwiftTrader DiamondStartTrader (for reference)
Size & price compared (incl. tax)Sapphire, ¥20M, ¥109,800Platinum, ¥20M, ¥93,800¥35M, ¥179,800Master, ¥20M, ¥84,800
Price as % of account ($100K equiv.)0.549% ($549)0.469% ($469)0.514% ($513.71)0.424% ($424)
Steps & target2-step, 8%→6%1-step, 6%Same3-step, 2%→3%→6%
Daily loss5% (based on equity at 00:00 UTC)2% (same basis)Same3% (same basis)
Overall loss10% (based on initial capital, static)3% (same basis)Same6% (same basis)
Overall loss after payoutDoesn't moveDoesn't moveDoesn't moveDoesn't move
Minimum trading days3 days per step3 daysSame3 days per step
Time limitNoneEvaluation capped at 60 daysSame180 days per step
Daily profit cap during evaluationNone3% of initial capitalSame40% of profit target
Profit split80%90%100%50–100% (variable)
Payout requirementEvery 2 weeks, min ¥20,000Every 2 weeks, ≥3% of initial capital in profit, every timeSameEvery 2 weeks
Leverage100xFX & gold 25x / indices 20x / BTC 2xSame—
Fee refundContract fee refunded at Dojo White BeltContract fee refunded at Dojo White BeltSameNot eligible
Max concurrent funded accountsUp to ¥50M combinedUp to ¥35M combinedSameUp to ¥20M combined

"Overall loss after payout" doesn't move on any plan. The official help center states that "the overall loss rate is always based on initial capital and does not change even after a payout is made." SwiftTrader keeps its −3% overall and −2% daily (equity) limits after funding too.

The "Scaling Dojo" is a program that launched on June 3, 2026. At the first rank, "White Belt," once you satisfy 20 active trading days (days with a new order) and 2 payouts received, you receive a contract fee equal to what you paid at purchase. Promotion isn't automatic — it requires an application. SwiftTrader is only eligible for accounts opened on or after August 18, 2025; StartTrader is not eligible.

StartTrader is not included in this simulation. During evaluation, its daily profit is capped at 40% of the profit target (0.8% at Step 1), and its split varies between 50–100%, so it can't be represented correctly in the same model.

SwiftTrader was overhauled on July 15, 2026

Before (through July 14, 2026)After (from July 15, 2026)
Profit target10%6%
Daily loss rate−3%−2%
Overall loss rate−6%−3%
Evaluation periodUnlimitedUp to 60 days
Profit split100%90% (100% for Diamond only)
Daily profit cap during evaluation—3%
¥20M price—¥93,800

The target and price came down, but in exchange the loss allowance was halved, a time limit was added, and the split went down. Accounts bought before the revision keep the 10% target, 3% daily, and 6% overall.

The official help article "How are the Daily loss limit and Maximum Loss limit calculated?" (updated March 17, 2026) still says "SwiftTrader: 3% daily, 6% overall." That's leftover pre-revision text; the purchase page and the revision notice (updated July 15) say 2% / 3%. Don't buy based on the old one.

SwiftTrader's bucket next to FTMO and E8

Rules as confirmed on each firm's official site on September 20, 2026, normalized to $100K equivalent (¥20M).

SwiftTraderChallengeFTMO 2-StepFTMO 1-StepE8 Pro 8%E8 One 6%
Steps12 (8→6%)2 (10→5%)1 (10%)1 (8%)1 (9%)
Daily loss−2% (equity)−5%−5% (based on initial balance, from the day's opening balance)−3%−2.5%−4%
Overall loss−3% static−10% static−10% static−10% EOD trailing (follows the highest balance)−8% static (moves to the initial balance on the first payout)−6% dynamic (follows the highest confirmed balance, locks at the initial balance)
Time limit60 daysNoneNoneNoneNoneNone
Minimum trading days33 each4 eachNoneNoneNone
Profit cap / consistency3%/day in evaluation / payouts need +3% eachNoneNoneBest day 50%2%/day (excess deleted), payouts up to 50% of profit40% consistency in the funded stage
Split90%80%80→90%90%80%80%
Fee (% of account)0.469% (¥93,800)0.549% (¥109,800)0.540% ($540)0.499% ($499)0.366% ($488→$366, code E8)0.366% (same)
Fee per ¥10,000 of loss allowance¥1,563¥549¥540¥499¥458¥610
Target ÷ loss allowance2.00.8 (Phase 1)1.0 (Phase 1)1.01.01.5

Three numbers tell you how big the bucket is.

1. Fee per ¥10,000 of loss allowance. SwiftTrader charges ¥93,800 for a 3% = ¥600,000 allowance: ¥1,563 per ¥10,000. Challenge charges ¥109,800 for 10% = ¥2M: ¥549. SwiftTrader has the cheapest sticker price, but divided by how much you're allowed to lose, you pay 2.5–3.4x what the other five charge.

2. Target ÷ loss allowance. SwiftTrader is 6% ÷ 3% = 2.0. Challenge is 8% ÷ 10% = 0.8, FTMO and E8 Pro are 1.0, E8 One is 1.5. "Win twice what you're allowed to lose" applies only to SwiftTrader among the six.

3. How much you can fire per day. The −2% daily limit is equity-based; at 3 trades a day the cap per trade is 0.66% (three losses = −1.98%). Even at one trade a day the cap is 1.9%, and at that size the second stop-loss breaks the −3% overall limit. Challenge's daily limit is 5%, so one trade a day can go up to 4.9%. SwiftTrader's leverage is also only 25x, so you can't open large positions in the first place.

SwiftTrader's six pitfalls

1. The −3% overall limit doesn't move in the funded stage. The help article "What rules do I have to follow to keep my SwiftTrader account?" says "maximum loss −3% static, daily −2% equity." After you pass, lose 3% and you're done.

2. The −2% daily limit is equity-based. You fail the instant equity drops 2% from its 00:00 UTC (9:00 JST) level, floating losses included. A swing position carrying floating loss always risks touching 2% overnight.

3. Every payout needs +3% profit. The purchase page lists a "+3% profit target per payout," and the help center says payouts unlock "once you reach the Minimum profit per payout." A payout pulls profit out of the account, so you have to build 3% again before the next one. Periods that fall short just accumulate, and touching −3% in the meantime wipes everything. Challenge, FTMO, and E8 have no profit target like this in the funded stage.

4. Daily profit tops out at 3% during evaluation. Hit the cap and all positions are closed automatically, with no trading until 00:00 UTC (9:00 JST) the next day. You can't take 6% in one day to pass; it takes at least 3 days. Evaluation means −2%/−3% loss limits and a +3% profit cap; the funded stage means a −3% loss limit and +3% per payout. SwiftTrader is trading inside a box bounded by 3% at every stage.

5. The 60-day limit. That's 42 trading days. Size down and you won't make it in time, so you rebuy even without blowing up. In the 120-trading-day calculation at 0.25% per trade (3 a day), about 70% of zero-edge accounts and about two-thirds of small-edge accounts ended by expiring.

6. Leverage is 25x. That's a quarter of Challenge's 100x. With such a small loss allowance the practical impact is limited, but methods that open large gold or index positions simply don't fit.

Expected value ①: 1-year take-home (rebuying after every fail)

Assumptions

Fixed

  • 1 year (250 trading days), max 3 trades/day, take-profit and stop-loss at 1:1
  • Daily loss capped at 2.5% of initial balance across every plan (on a day when one more loss would exceed 2.5% or the firm's daily limit, you stop trading for the day)
  • Risk per trade, floating loss, and daily loss never exceed 3% (assumed not to trigger Fintokei's "3% maximum allowable risk on open positions")
  • Lot size fixed at r% of initial balance, one position at a time
  • Cost is 5% of risk per trade (win = +0.95R, loss = −1.05R)
  • On a fail, the same plan is repurchased; no scaling; payouts every 14 days; profit left in the account at year-end is not counted
  • Scaling Dojo: the fee is refunded once a funded account trades for 20+ days and receives its 2nd payout
  • 20,000 runs per condition

Varied

  • Plan
  • Skill: 50% win rate (zero) / 52% (small) / 55% (medium) / 58% (strong)
  • Risk per trade r (0.5% / 1.0% / 1.5%)
  • Amount of profit left in the account at payout time (we picked whichever amount was best for each plan)

SwiftTrader's daily limit is 2%, so in practice it stops at 2% before the "2.5% per day" rule. At 1.5% per trade, one loss ends the day.

Not modeled

  • SwiftTrader's daily profit cap during evaluation (3% of initial capital). At 0.5% and 1% risk the maximum daily profit is under 3%, so it never triggers, but at 1.5% it triggers on days with 3 wins in a row, so SwiftTrader's 1.5% numbers look better than reality.
  • SwiftTrader's evaluation time limit (60 days max). The smaller the risk per trade, the longer it takes to hit the target, so SwiftTrader's 0.5% numbers look better than reality.
  • The number of trading days required to request a payout (the help center says 3; the payout-request article says 5 for SwiftTrader). The model trades every day, so this is met at a 2-week request cadence.
  • Challenge's ¥20,000 minimum payout (0.1% of a ¥20M account). Two weeks of profit almost always clears it, so the impact is small.
  • News trading, holding over the weekend, swaps, and Scaling Dojo tiers above White Belt (capital increases).

The expected-value formula

With take-profit and stop-loss at 1:1 and cost set at 5% of risk per trade (0.05R), a win nets +0.95R and a loss costs −1.05R. With win rate p:

Expected value per trade = p × 0.95R − (1 − p) × 1.05R = (2p − 1.05) × R

SkillWin rate pExpected value per trade
Zero50%−0.05R
Small52%−0.01R
Medium55%+0.05R
Strong58%+0.11R

Expected value per year = average payouts received + average fee refunded − average fee paid

  • Payouts received = withdrawal amount × split (Challenge 80%, SwiftTrader 90%, Diamond 100%)
  • Fee refunded: equal amount at Scaling Dojo White Belt (2nd payout)
  • Fee paid = fee × number of purchases in the year (rebought after every fail)

Losses are capped at "fee × number of purchases," while payouts from a passing account have no ceiling. Because of this shape, a slightly negative expected value per trade can still turn positive over a year. These averages can't be derived from a formula, so we ran 20,000 simulated years of trading under the actual rules and averaged them (Monte Carlo).

On a ¥20M account at 1% risk, the risk is ¥200,000. One pip on USD/JPY is ¥1,000 per lot (100,000 units), so with a 30-pip stop that's ¥200,000 ÷ (30 pips × ¥1,000) = about 6.7 lots. If round-trip cost is 1.5 pips, cost is 5% of risk — the same weight as this article's assumption. The detailed calculation is in our 4-firm comparison article.

0.5% risk per trade: average annual take-home minus fees

SkillChallengeSwiftTraderSwiftTrader Diamond
Zero−$1,481−$2,919−$3,168
Small−$98+$1,026+$1,197
Medium+$7,002+$11,467+$12,775
Strong+$21,619+$28,482+$31,656

Probability of finishing positive at "medium" edge: Challenge 71%, SwiftTrader 90%, Diamond 90%.

1.0% risk per trade

SkillChallengeSwiftTraderSwiftTrader Diamond
Zero−$996−$1,068−$1,045
Small+$4,363+$5,864+$6,635
Medium+$21,609+$21,285+$23,739
Strong+$49,570+$50,453+$56,082

Probability of finishing positive at "medium" edge: Challenge 92%, SwiftTrader 93%, Diamond 93%.

1.5% risk per trade

At 1.5% per trade, one loss ends SwiftTrader's day (2% daily), and losing two days in a row breaks the 3% overall limit.

SkillChallengeSwiftTraderSwiftTrader Diamond
Zero+$1,405+$865+$1,217
Small+$8,678+$11,905+$13,452
Medium+$28,146+$34,645+$38,671
Strong+$58,525+$68,320+$75,991

SwiftTrader in this table doesn't include the 3% evaluation profit cap or the 60-day limit, so the real numbers are lower. In the 120-trading-day calculation below, adding those two puts SwiftTrader at 1.5% at a 100% fail rate per account. This table is positive because it keeps rebuying after each fail and counts the payouts once some later account gets there.

Why the gap appears

PlanWhat's driving it
ChallengeA wide bucket (10% overall, 5% daily), so failing is less likely. The 8%→6% two-step target is slow to reach payout. The fee comes back at Dojo White Belt
SwiftTraderOne step with a 6% target reaches payout fast. 90% split. But a narrow bucket (3% overall, 2% daily) means more fails and rebuys
SwiftTrader DiamondSame rules as SwiftTrader with a 100% split. At 0.514% of the account, it costs little more than Platinum (0.469%)

SwiftTrader's weakness is how often you rebuy. At 1% risk and "medium" edge, the average fee paid over a year was $1,741 for Challenge vs. $6,268 for SwiftTrader, rising to $9,119 at zero edge. Faster payouts only win that back if you have edge.

Expected value ②: 120-trading-day multiples (with SwiftTrader's time limit and profit cap)

We also ran a separate calculation that includes the SwiftTrader conditions the 1-year model leaves out. 40,000 Monte Carlo runs; each trade wins +R×r with probability p and loses −r otherwise. 3 trades a day, 120 trading days. After passing, the account enters the funded stage with a payout check every 10 trading days (biweekly). SwiftTrader includes "no payout unless +3% is reached," "expires at 60 days (42 trading days)," and "stop for the day at +3% during evaluation"; Challenge has no time limit, no payout condition, and no profit cap. It follows a single account, with no rebuy and no Scaling Dojo refund.

Multiple = expected payout ÷ fee; 1.0x is break-even.

Multiple (expected payout ÷ fee) by risk per trade and skill. SwiftTrader breaks above 0.66%, while Challenge keeps growing as lot size rises
SkillRisk per tradeSwiftTrader multipleDays to fundedFail rateChallenge multipleDays to fundedFail rate
Zero edge 50%, RR 1.00.50%1.2324 days98.6%0.4982 days34.9%
0.66%1.8819 days99.5%1.4670 days54.2%
1.50%0.16—100%4.7125 days98.5%
Small edge 50%, RR 1.20.50%11.5420 days88.3%10.0467 days6.7%
1.00%0.25—100%27.8833 days59.6%
1.50%0.44—100%29.3318 days88.9%
Decent 55%, RR 1.20.50%42.2617 days56.1%34.7846 days0.4%
1.50%1.40—100%100.4914 days55.2%
Strong 60%, RR 1.20.50%85.9013 days25.5%63.2230 days0.0%
0.66%93.2310 days53.6%89.7124 days0.2%
1.50%4.07—100%203.3711 days21.6%
  • At the same lot size, SwiftTrader wins at 0.5% or less. It passes faster (13–20 days vs. 30–67), pays 90%, and costs less
  • Above 1% per trade, SwiftTrader breaks (100% fail rate). Challenge keeps growing as you size up
  • If you're free to pick your lot size, Challenge wins at every skill level (best vs. best: 4.7x vs. 1.9x, 29x vs. 11.5x, 100x vs. 42x, 203x vs. 93x)

This assumes you can fire 3 times a day. A once-a-day method moves a third as much risk per day, which on SwiftTrader pushes you toward not reaching 6% in 60 days and more expiries.

It passes once, but doesn't survive

What happens to SwiftTrader accounts: breakdown of fails (loss limit), expiries, and survivors at the end

SwiftTrader shows a high fail rate and a decent multiple at the same time. At 55% and 0.5% the fail rate is 56%, and at 50%/RR 1.2 and 0.5% it's 88%, yet the multiples are 42x and 11.5x.

The reason is that it "passes fast and pays out a few times before dying." The −3% overall limit stays in place after funding, so a day that loses 3% eventually comes. But funding takes only 13–20 days and payouts are biweekly, so an average of 1–4 payouts land before the account dies. SwiftTrader's value is set not by account lifespan but by speed to funding × number of payouts.

Size down, and expiry becomes the main way accounts end. Reaching 6% in 60 days takes a lot size that roughly uses up the daily room.

Which should you buy?

Your situationRecommendation
You don't know yet whether you can winChallenge (smallest loss at zero edge)
You have big losing days or streaksChallenge (room of 5% daily, 10% overall)
One trade a day, 1%+ per tradeChallenge (SwiftTrader expires if you size small and fails at −3% if you size big)
Swing trading with floating lossesChallenge (SwiftTrader's −2% daily limit is equity-based)
A high-win-rate method firing 3+ times a day at 0.3–0.5% per tradeSwiftTrader (Diamond if budget allows)
A beginner who wants to try slowly with a small amountStartTrader is an option, but the split starts at 50% and it's not eligible for the refund (not calculated in this article)

If you buy SwiftTrader, buy one ¥20M account (0.469%), use it for high-frequency trading at 3+ trades a day and 0.5% or less per trade, and buy it on the assumption that you're fine with it ending once you've earned back the fee. In the −2% daily / −3% overall box, going above 0.5% makes failing the main outcome.

SwiftTrader funded accounts are capped at ¥35M combined. Holding a Diamond (¥35M) means you can't hold any other SwiftTrader funded account.

If you just want a 1-step plan, E8 Pro 8% (¥458, 1.0) and FTMO 1-Step (¥499, 1.0) are better on fee per loss allowance and target ÷ loss allowance; SwiftTrader (¥1,563, 2.0) is the outlier on both.

👉 🎁 Fintokei affiliate link

FAQ

Q. Is Fintokei's expected value positive?

At 1% risk and a 55% win rate (+0.05R per trade), Challenge makes +$21,609 a year — about ¥4.32M on a ¥20M account. At a 50% win rate (zero edge) it was negative except at 1.5% risk, and that small positive disappears with a bit more cost. Choosing a plan doesn't create an edge on its own.

Q. Which is better, SwiftTrader or Challenge?

If you take risk up to the rule limit, Challenge. In the calculation that includes SwiftTrader's 60-day limit and evaluation profit cap, Challenge won at every skill level when each plan used its best lot size. SwiftTrader only wins for high-frequency methods at 3+ trades a day and 0.5% or less per trade. In the 1-year calculation without the time limit and profit cap, SwiftTrader came out ahead at win rates of 52%+, Challenge at 50%, and they were about even at 1% risk and 55%.

Q. Does Fintokei refund the fee?

At the Scaling Dojo's White Belt you receive a contract fee equal to what you paid. The conditions are 20 active trading days and 2 payouts received, and you must apply through support. Eligible plans are Challenge (including Swing and Slim) and SwiftTrader (accounts from August 18, 2025); StartTrader is not eligible.

Q. When can I withdraw (request payouts) from Fintokei, and how much?

The first request is possible 2 weeks after your first trade on the funded account, then every 2 weeks. Challenge's minimum request is ¥20,000. SwiftTrader requires "at least 3% of initial capital in profit" every time — ¥600,000 on a ¥20M account. All positions must be closed when you request.

Q. What happens to SwiftTrader accounts bought before the revision?

The official help center lists "accounts purchased before July 15, 2026" separately: they keep the 10% target, 3% daily, and 6% overall. Buying again puts you on the revised rules.

Q. FTMO 1-Step is also a 1-step plan — how is it different from SwiftTrader?

The allowance is 10% (SwiftTrader: 3%), there's no time limit, and the daily limit is −3%. In exchange, max loss is EOD trailing, following the highest balance, so the fail line rises as profit builds. Even so, the fee per loss allowance is ¥499 (a third of SwiftTrader's), and target ÷ loss allowance is 1.0.

Q. What about E8 Pro?

It has the cheapest fee per loss allowance of the six (¥458) and a target ÷ loss allowance of 1.0. The catch is the "2% daily profit cap": anything above it is deleted from the account the next day. Also, the fail line rises to the initial balance the moment you request the first payout, and you can only request half of your profit. Details are in E8 Markets' expected value.

Q. How does it compare to Moneta's 1-Step?

Moneta's 1-Step as of September 2026 (10% target, 6% static max, 3% daily) had a target ÷ loss allowance of 1.67; SwiftTrader's 2.0 is heavier still and comes with a 60-day limit. Note that Moneta rebuilt its 1-Step in October 2026: newly bought accounts have a 5% trailing max loss, fail instantly at 1% floating loss, and list at $1,098 for $100K.

Q. Can I use an EA?

The purchase page says "EA OK." But Fintokei prohibits running commercial or free EAs without adjustment; it has to be your own EA or one whose parameters you've tuned yourself (see the Fintokei guide). A self-built, high-frequency, low-lot EA is one of the few combinations SwiftTrader suits.

Q. Does SwiftTrader also have the 3% rule?

Yes: "maximum allowable risk on open positions −3%." Since the overall loss allowance is also 3%, it effectively means the combined risk of open positions can't exceed the account's entire allowance. The help center says a violation isn't an instant fail; it's a warning, after which the consistency rule is applied.

Q. Fintokei prices in yen — why show dollars?

To compare with other firms on the same yardstick. Fees, targets, and loss limits are all normalized to a percentage of account size. Sapphire (¥20M) at ¥109,800 is 0.549% of the account, so $549 at $100K equivalent. To convert to yen, multiply the table amounts by "account size ÷ $100K" (×200 for ¥20M).

Q. I want to run this with my own numbers

We've published the 1-year simulation script and this article's plan config file. python sim-prop-ev.py fintokei.json reproduces the same tables. You can change win rate, lot size, cost, and the daily loss cap (requires Python and numba). The 120-trading-day calculation is scripts/sim-fintokei-swift-vs-pro.py (charts from scripts/plot-fintokei-swift-vs-pro.py).

Assumptions and limits

  • The 1-year calculation doesn't include SwiftTrader's 60-day limit or the evaluation daily profit cap. The 120-trading-day calculation follows a single account and doesn't include rebuys or the Scaling Dojo refund
  • The 120-trading-day calculation fixes 3 trades a day and excludes spread, slippage, swaps, and news. "+3% per payout" is modeled as "withdraw everything if the account is +3% over the initial balance at the end of the cycle"
  • Both calculations assume trades are independent
  • FTMO rules are from the official Trading Objectives page (2-Step: 10% static max loss, 5% daily from the day's opening balance; 1-Step: 10% EOD trailing max loss, 3% daily, best day 50%). FTMO prices ($100K 2-Step $540 / 1-Step $499) are third-party data (PropFirm Key, March 11, 2026) because the price table on the official page is rendered by JS and couldn't be retrieved
  • E8 rules and price ($366 after code E8) are from our September 13, 2026 review

Sources: Fintokei "Challenge plan", "SwiftTrader plan", "StartTrader plan", "Scaling Dojo"; official help center: "Challenge plan step rules", "SwiftTrader plan step rules", "SwiftTrader data fee", "StartTrader plan step rules", "How loss rates are calculated", "Payout request requirements", "Can I open multiple trading accounts?" (all confirmed September 27, 2026); "How does SwiftTrader Challenge work? What are the rules?", "What rules do I have to follow to keep my SwiftTrader account?", "What leverage do you offer?", "What is SwiftTrader program?" (updated July 15, 2026). FTMO: ftmo.com/en/trading-objectives, /en/2-step-challenge, /en/1-step-challenge (confirmed September 20, 2026); prices from propfirmkey.com "FTMO Challenge Cost 2026" (March 11, 2026).

Written by

Hosono P | the prop firm strategist

I buy challenges with my own money and record everything through to the payout. Recorded payouts: ¥6.1M in total from Fintokei, Fundora and Funded7, plus $14,297 from The5ers and RZR Funded (as of November 2026). Author of the semi-discretionary EA "ELDRA".

Profile and payout recordX @hosono_p

📚Related articles

🧪

E8 Markets Expected Value and Plan Comparison: E8 Pro's "2% Daily Profit Cap" and "Max Loss Rises to the Initial Balance on the First Payout" — Size Up and E8 One Wins [November 2026]

A Monte Carlo of E8 Markets' E8 One, E8 Pro (80%/100% split), and E8 Signature, run to the official rules: 1-year take-home at 0.5%/1%/1.5% risk and 50–58% win rates, return multiples on the fee, and break-even win rates. Also covers how E8 Pro's 2% daily profit cap (excess deleted the next day) and 50%-of-profit payouts with the max-loss line rising on the first payout really bite, when to request payouts, the structural differences between E8 Pro and E8 One, lot-size ceilings, which configuration to pick (DD 6/8/10%, split 80/100%), fit for account rotation (vs. Breakout Prop and The5ers), and prices for every size.

Research9/27/2026
🧪

FTMO vs. FundedElite: Which Should You Buy? | A 1-Year Simulation of 5 Plans Under the Same Assumptions Puts FTMO 1-Step on Top, With FundedElite's Lite Putting Up a Good Fight [September 2026]

A 1-year Monte Carlo comparison of FTMO (2-Step / 1-Step) and FundedElite (2-Step / 2-Step Lite / 1-Step), run strictly to the official rules of each. Covers expected value at 0.5%/1%/1.5% risk per trade and 50–58% win rates, plus the differences in EA rules, refunds, free retries, and coupons.

Research9/28/2026
🧪

FTMO vs. The5ers vs. Fintokei vs. RZR (formerly Hantec): Expected Value Compared | Cap Daily Loss at 2.5% and Run 7 Plans for a Year — FTMO 1-Step Comes Out on Top [September 2026]

I compared 7 plans — FTMO (2-Step / 1-Step), The5ers High Stakes (Classic / New), the Fintokei challenge, and RZR (Enhanced / Endurance) — with a year-long Monte Carlo simulation that follows each firm's official rules exactly. Capping daily loss at 2.5% across every plan puts FTMO 1-Step in first place at every lot size, followed by Fintokei and FTMO 2-Step.

Research9/27/2026
🧪

Tradeify FX Expected Value and Its 3 Plans Compared | With November's NOV 45% Off, Direct Ranks #1 at Every Skill Level; 2-Step Classic Has Reversed 5%→10% Targets and a 10% Static Max Loss [November 2026]

We ran Tradeify FX's 2-Step Classic, 1-Step Daily and Direct (the FX version of the US futures prop firm Tradeify) through a 1-year Monte Carlo simulation using the official rules, at November's NOV coupon price (45% off your first 5 orders). Covers annual take-home at 0.5%/1%/1.5% risk per trade and 50–58% win rates, prices for every size, the max loss after payouts, the 10-minute news rule, the trader check-in (KYT), the move to Live after 5 payouts, and the EA rules. The site owner also bought a 2-Step Classic on November 7.

Research11/7/2026
🧪

What's FTMO's Expected Value? A One-Year Simulation of 2-Step vs. 1-Step Shows 1-Step Wins at Every Lot Size [September 2026]

We ran FTMO's 2-Step and 1-Step ($100K) through a one-year Monte Carlo simulation using the official rules. Covers the annual take-home at 0.5%/1%/1.5% risk per trade and 50–58% win rates, how 2-Step's 100% fee refund and 1-Step's "the account resets on every payout" mechanism play out.

Research9/27/2026
🧪

What's FundedHive's Expected Value? Simulating 2-Step Classic Over 1 Year: It Falls Short of FTMO Due to a 70% Split and a $1,000 Daily Payout Cap [September 2026]

A 1-year Monte Carlo of FundedHive's 2-Step Classic ($499 for $100K), run to the official rules. Covers annual take-home at 0.5%/1%/1.5% risk per trade and 50–58% win rates, and explains the impact of the 70% profit split, the $1,000-a-day payout cap, and a static max loss that doesn't move on a payout, lined up against FTMO 2-Step.

Research9/27/2026