πŸ§ͺ Research

TradeDay Expected Value, Calculated (September 2026) | At Zero Edge, Quick Pay Intraday Nets +$2,522/Year - But Gains Plateau, and VPS Is Banned

Published: 9/25/2026

* Prices and rules were confirmed against TradeDay's official pricing card (tradeday.com) and help center (tradeday.freshdesk.com) on September 25, 2026. The figures below are Monte Carlo results and do not guarantee future performance.

πŸ“’ Advertising/affiliate disclosure: This site does not hold an affiliate link for TradeDay.

TL;DR

  • At zero edge, go with Quick Pay Intraday $50K ($59/month, stops billing once you pass). At 0.30 lots: +$2,522/year, 85% chance of finishing positive. This is the best result in Category B (self-built automation only), tying Topstep (+$2,519)
  • But gains don't scale well even when you win. Quick Pay's split is 50% (only the portion above the current $4,000 profit gets 80%), and the sim account caps out at $10,000 in cumulative profit. Even with "medium" edge, that's only +$8,424/year
  • If you have real edge, go with Fast Pass EOD ($85/month). At "medium" edge: +$9,920/year
  • VPS is banned. Off-the-shelf bots are banned too - automated trading is allowed only if it's self-built using the built-in features of NinjaTrader, Tradovate, TradingView, etc.
  • Doesn't come close to FTMO Futures Pro (+$4,836 at zero edge, +$26,306 at "medium")

Prices and Rules ($50K, measured September 25, 2026)

Quick Pay IntradayQuick Pay EODFast Pass EOD
Price$59/month (list $131)$79/month (list $175)$85/month (list $189)
Reset$60$85$85
Activation feeNoneNoneNone
Evaluation target / max loss$3,000 / $2,000, trailing (also tracks floating profit)$3,000 / $2,000, EOD-basedSame as left
Evaluation consistency / min. days30% / 5 days30% / 5 days45% / 3 days
Daily lossNone (during and after evaluation)NoneNone
Max loss after passingTrailing (also tracks floating profit), locks at starting balanceSame as leftEOD-based, locks at starting balance on first payout
Consistency after passingNoneNone45%
Payout conditionsAny time you're in profit (min. $250)Same as left5 profitable days of $150+ each
Per-payout capNoneNoneUp to 50% of balance / $1,500
Split50% on the portion up to $4,000 of current profit, 80% above thatSame as left80%
Sim account endCaps out at $10,000 cumulative profit (anything above is forfeited) β†’ moves to liveSame as leftMoves to live on the 5th payout
  • Consistency isn't a failure condition - if the biggest single day exceeds the cap, the profit target simply goes up
  • The monthly fee only applies during evaluation, and billing stops the moment you pass. If the evaluation is still failed on the renewal date, the renewal includes a reset
  • Live accounts get a 90% split. However, CME's professional market data fee ($156+$2/month) applies, and the account is closed out if the balance drops below $500
  • Fees are $2.40 round trip for MGC (official, includes exchange and NFA fees)
  • Trustpilot 4.6 (1,439 reviews). Japan is not on the restricted list

Automated Trading and VPS

Key points from the official help article "Automated, Algo and Bot Trading":

To use an automated trading system, you must use one of the platforms we support: NinjaTrader, Tradovate, TradingView, Jigsaw and Quantower. TradeDay does not expose the Tradovate API… Algos and Bots purchased from a third party and employed by the trader are forbidden. If multiple users are making the same trades, then all the accounts will be shut down.

  • Automated trading is allowed only if it's self-built using the supported platforms' built-in features. No API is provided
  • More than 200 trades a day, splitting orders, and hedging across accounts are all banned
  • VPS is banned ("TradeDay does not allow the use of virtual private servers (VPS)"). You also need to turn off VPN and iCloud Private Relay - when moving to live or requesting a payout, there's a check that you traded a full day from your registered address
  • Copying your own trades across accounts is allowed for up to 10 accounts (5 sim + 5 live)

If you want to run a bot 24 hours a day, you need to leave a PC running at home.

Assumptions

Same as the FTMO Futures expected-value article.

  • One trade per trading day in Micro Gold (MGC). With a 0.6% stop loss, the loss on 0.10 lots (1 MGC contract) is $262
  • Same lot size during evaluation and after passing. One year (252 trading days)
  • Price is the monthly fee shown on the pricing card (the price shown under the "55% off" label)
  • For Quick Pay's split, since withdrawing daily means "current profit" almost never exceeds $4,000, we use 50% for the calculation (the conservative side)
  • The sim account is cut off at $10,000 cumulative profit (Quick Pay) or 5 payouts (Fast Pass); nothing counts after moving to live

Result 1: Annual Expected Value at a Fixed 0.30 Lots

EdgeQuick Pay IntradayQuick Pay EODFast Pass EOD
βˆ’0.10Rβˆ’$67βˆ’$753βˆ’$1,814
βˆ’0.04R+$1,394+$723βˆ’$397
Zero edge+$2,522 (85%)+$1,872 (76%)+$848 (55%)
Small (50% win rate, 1.2 payoff ratio)+$4,529+$3,952+$4,377
Medium (55% win rate, 1.2 payoff ratio)+$8,424+$7,886+$9,920
Strong (60% win rate, 1.2 payoff ratio)+$13,219+$12,765+$15,985

Figures in parentheses are the probability of finishing positive. "Strong" is a reference value that essentially no one hits in reality.

  • Quick Pay Intraday is close to breakeven even for a losing trader (+$1,394 at βˆ’0.04R). At just $59/month, and since you can withdraw right after a winning day once you've passed, you can claw the fee back gradually before losing the account
  • But it doesn't scale upward. The 50% split and the $10,000 cumulative cutoff cap it at +$8,424/year even at "medium" edge - less than half of other firms
  • The evaluation's max loss should in theory be stricter for Intraday (which tracks floating profit) than EOD, but Intraday came out ahead anyway since it's $20/month cheaper and the reset is $25 cheaper too

Result 2: Cash Flow (0.30 lots)

Annual costAnnual receiptsEvaluation passesPayout countTimes the post-pass account was lost
Quick Pay Intraday, zero edge$2,500$5,0227.813.07.7
Quick Pay Intraday, medium$2,000$10,42411.622.711.3
Fast Pass EOD, medium$1,565$11,4857.59.95.7

With Quick Pay, even at "medium" edge you pass 11 times a year and lose the account 11 times. Because you withdraw after every winning day, there's no cushion left in the account, so it's easy to hit the max loss right after passing. Since the most you can pull from one account is $10,000 cumulative (and the take-home is half of that), the pattern becomes passing and failing over and over, collecting money in small pieces.

Comparison with FTMO Futures and Topstep ($50K, 0.30 lots)

EdgeTradeDay Quick Pay IntradayTradeDay Fast Pass EODFTMO Futures ProTopstep
Zero edge+$2,522+$848+$4,836+$2,519
Medium+$8,424+$9,920+$26,306+$24,982

Caveats

  • The official pricing is inconsistent across TradeDay's own materials. The pricing card shows $131/$175/$189 with 55% off, coming to $59/$79/$85, while the help center (dated September 1) shows list prices of $125/$175/$180. The reset fees also differ between the card ($59/$79/$85) and the help center's table ($60/$85/$85)
  • The discount rate for the banner coupon TDNEW has not been confirmed
  • Trading during major economic releases is restricted (separate article, not yet confirmed)

FAQ

Q. Which plan should I buy?

If you're not confident in your edge, go with Quick Pay Intraday $50K ($59/month). Even at zero edge it came out to +$2,522/year, with an 85% chance of finishing positive. If you do have edge, Fast Pass EOD is the pick, but even then "medium" edge only gets you +$9,920/year - less than half of FTMO Futures or Topstep.

Q. Can I run an EA on a VPS?

No. TradeDay explicitly bans VPS use, and there's a check - at payout request time and when moving to live - that you're trading from your registered address.

Simulation script: scripts/sim-futures-b-ev.py (engine: scripts/sim-futures-prop-ev.py)

Written by

Hosono P | the prop firm strategist

I buy challenges with my own money and record everything through to the payout. Recorded payouts: Β₯6.1M in total from Fintokei, Fundora and Funded7, plus $14,297 from The5ers and RZR Funded (as of November 2026). Author of the semi-discretionary EA "ELDRA".

Profile and payout recordX @hosono_p

πŸ“šRelated articles

πŸ§ͺ

Expected Value of 11 Futures Prop Firms (September 2026) | Fully Automated OK (Category A) vs. Own Bots Only (Category B) Under the Same Conditions - FTMO Futures Pro Comes Out on Top

A roundup comparing the $50K accounts of 11 futures prop firms that allow automated trading, under the same Monte Carlo conditions: the fully-automated-OK Category A firms (FTMO Futures, FundedNext Futures, MyFundedFutures, Lucid Trading, BluSky, FFN) and the own-bots-only Category B firms (Bulenox, Tradeify, TradeDay, The Trading Pit, Topstep). At 0.30 lots, 1 micro gold trade a day, over 1 year: at zero edge, FTMO Futures Pro wins with +$4,836 a year, followed by BluSky Propel +$2,988, TradeDay Quick Pay Intraday +$2,522, and Topstep +$2,519. At 'medium' edge FTMO Pro still wins at +$26,306, but Bulenox Qualification, Topstep, Tradeify Select Daily, FFN STEADY, MFFU Rapid EOD, and Lucid Daily cluster between $24,000 and $25,500. Only FTMO, FundedNext, and The Trading Pit explicitly allow VPS.

Research9/25/2026
πŸ§ͺ

[September 2026] I Calculated The Trading Pit Futures's (Futures Prime) Expected Value | A $99 One-Time Fee Nets +$1,345/Year at Zero Edge, and Own EAs + VPS Are Explicitly Allowed

I calculated the expected value of The Trading Pit's futures challenge, Futures Prime $50K, with a year-long Monte Carlo simulation from evaluation through payouts. Confirmed on the official futures page and help center on September 25, 2026. $99 one-time fee, $79 reset, 30-day evaluation. At 0.30 lots: +$1,345/year at zero edge, +$21,491/year at 'medium' edge. It's one of the few futures prop firms that explicitly allows both your own EA and a VPS, but its Trustpilot rating is suspended for violating guidelines.

Research9/25/2026
πŸ§ͺ

FTMO Futures Complete Guide and Expected Value: Bots and VPS Explicitly Allowed, and Pro $50K Maxing Out the Daily Limit Is Best [November 2026]

One article covering both the rules and the expected value of FTMO Futures, the futures prop program FTMO launched on September 1, 2026. Its forbidden-practices page states "Automated trading is permitted," and VPS and VPN use are also explicitly allowed. Covers monthly fees, reset fees, and payout conditions for all 6 Growth and Pro plans, how EOD trailing drawdown works, the JST close-out deadline (5:10 AM summer / 6:10 AM winter), and whether it's usable from Japan, plus a 1-year Monte Carlo from evaluation through payouts. Why Pro $50K comes out at +$4,836/year even at zero edge, how Pro can kill your account if you withdraw too aggressively, and why changing lot size between evaluation and funded is a rule violation.

Research9/23/2026
πŸ§ͺ

FundedNext Futures Expected Value and How to Pick Your R:R | Flex at Zero Edge, Legacy With an Edge, and R:R 1:2+ Loses to the 40% Consistency Rule [September 2026]

Compared FundedNext Futures' 4 plans (Flex, Legacy, Rapid Pro, Rapid Daily) in a full year of Monte Carlo simulation from evaluation to payout. At zero edge, only Flex $50K comes out positive at +$1,388/year; with an edge, Legacy pulls ahead thanks to its larger withdrawal cap. Holding skill fixed and moving only R:R from 1:0.5 to 1:3, Flex, Legacy, and Rapid Pro do best at R:R 1:1 or lower, while R:R 1:2+ loses because the 40% consistency rule effectively raises the target (Rapid Daily is the exception). Covers prices, reset costs, payout conditions, how Flex and Rapid end an account after 5 payouts, the explicit VPS and automated-trading permission, the corrective program, the 10-second rule, the tight-bracket ban, and a comparison against FTMO Futures and Topstep.

Research9/23/2026
πŸ§ͺ

[September 2026] We Calculated BluSky's Expected Value: The 3-Stage Model Favors Propel (30OFF), +$2,988/Year at Zero Edge

We compared the three plans (Launch, Propel, Orbit) at futures prop BluSky Trading using a Monte Carlo simulation run for one year, from evaluation through payout. Verified pricing, reset fees, the Buffer Zone, and payout terms on the official help center and pricing page on September 25, 2026. It's a 3-stage model β€” Evaluation β†’ Buffer Zone β†’ Sim Funded β€” and failing the Buffer Zone doesn't send you back to redo the evaluation. At 0.30 lots and zero edge, Propel $50K (code 30OFF brings it to $112/month) is best at +$2,988/year. Orbit's 30-day deadline is a heavy burden, and it comes out negative at zero edge.

Research9/25/2026
πŸ§ͺ

Bulenox Expected Value and Full Plan Rules: Every Plan Is One-Time Payment. At Zero Edge, End-of-Day Momentum; With an Edge, Qualification [November 2026]

A Monte Carlo comparing futures prop firm Bulenox's $50K plans (Qualification and Momentum, each in trailing and end-of-day variants) over a full year from evaluation through payouts. The monthly subscription model is gone β€” every plan is a one-time payment. At 0.30 lots and zero edge, Momentum (end-of-day) is best at +$2,047/year; with 'medium' edge, Qualification leads at +$25,529. Also covers max loss, payout cushion, and activation fees by size, payouts and the consistency rule, trading hours in JST, the self-built-only automation rule, and a company profile.

Research9/25/2026