Expected Value of 11 Futures Prop Firms (September 2026) | Fully Automated OK (Category A) vs. Own Bots Only (Category B) Under the Same Conditions - FTMO Futures Pro Comes Out on Top
Note: Each firm's prices and rules were confirmed on its official site and help center between September 22β25, 2026. The figures are Monte Carlo results and don't guarantee future performance. Detailed calculations for each firm are in their individual articles.
β» On November 7, 2026, we merged "Expected-Value Summary for 5 Futures Props That Allow Self-Built Bots (Category B)" into this article.
π’ Advertising / Affiliate Disclosure: This site holds no affiliate links with any futures-focused firm.
TL;DR
- The subjects are the 6 firms classified as "fully automated OK (Category A)" in a full review of automated-trading rules across 28 futures prop firms, plus the 5 "own bots only, with conditions (Category B)" firms that are still selling new accounts (YRM stopped selling new accounts in September 2026)
- At zero edge, FTMO Futures Pro $50K wins ($139/month). At 0.30 lots, +$4,836 a year. 2nd is BluSky Propel at +$2,988 (A), 3rd TradeDay Quick Pay Intraday at +$2,522 (B), 4th Topstep at +$2,519 (B)
- FTMO Pro wins even at "medium" edge (+$26,306). But Bulenox Qualification +$25,529 (B), Topstep +$24,982 (B), Tradeify Select Daily +$24,218 (B), FFN STEADY +$24,104 (A), MFFU Rapid EOD +$24,039 (A), and Lucid Daily +$23,859 (A) all cluster close behind
- FFN is the only one negative at zero edge (even at best, β$312)
- If you're running a bot 24/7 on a VPS, go with FTMO, FundedNext, or The Trading Pit. These are the only 3 firms that explicitly allow VPS. TradeDay and Topstep ban it
- The difference between Categories A and B is "what kind of bot you can use," not expected value itself. On expected value alone, FTMO Futures Pro is #1 both at zero edge and with an edge
Comparing the 11 Firms ($50K)
| Category | Firm | Plan with the best EV | Price | Automated trading | VPS | Trustpilot |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A | FTMO Futures | Pro | $139/month (stops once you pass) | β Explicitly allowed (own bots assumed) | β Explicitly allowed | 4.8 (company-wide) |
| A | FundedNext Futures | Flex / Legacy | One-time $69.99 / $199.99 | β Explicitly allowed | β Allowed per the help center | 4.5 (company-wide) |
| A | MyFundedFutures | Builder / Rapid EOD | One-time $75 / $125 (CLUB) | β Allowed if it's your own configured strategy | Not stated | 4.9 |
| A | Lucid Trading | Flex (with daily loss) / Daily | One-time $90.20 / $119 | β Allowed | Not stated | 4.4 |
| A | BluSky | Propel | $112/month (30OFF, stops once you pass) | β Allowed | Not stated | 4.7 |
| A | FFN | Standard MAX / STEADY | $160/month / one-time $229 | β At the firm's discretion | Not stated | 3.8 |
| B | Bulenox | Momentum (end-of-day) / Qualification (end-of-day) | One-time $143 / $175 + $148 on passing | Own bots only. No commercial, shared, or rented tools. Third-party API is $100/month | No stated policy | 4.7 |
| B | Tradeify | Growth / Select Daily | One-time $145 / $165 | Ownership proven by live video. Same bot at multiple firms not allowed | Login not allowed; trading at your own risk | 4.4 |
| B | TradeDay | Quick Pay Intraday / Fast Pass EOD | $59/month / $85/month (stops once you pass) | Own bots using supported platforms' built-in features. No API, no commercial bots | Banned | 4.6 |
| B | The Trading Pit | Futures Prime | One-time $99 | Own EAs allowed. No others' signals, no HFT | β Explicitly allowed | Suspended |
| B | Topstep | Plan with activation fee | $49/month (stops once you pass) + $149 on passing | Via TopstepX API ($29/month). Not allowed on live accounts | Banned (home PC only) | 3.6 |
Firms with 2 "best plans" listed are ones where the ranking flips between zero edge and having an edge (left is zero edge, right is with an edge).
Assumptions (Common to All Firms)
- 1 trade a day on micro gold (MGC). At a 0.6% stop-loss, the loss on 0.10 lots (1 MGC contract) is $262
- Standardized at $50K, 0.30 lots (FTMO Pro's $1,000 hard daily loss caps it at 0.30)
- Same lot size on the evaluation and post-pass account. 1 year (252 trading days). Profit left in the account after 1 year and anything after moving to a live account isn't counted
- Reset on disqualification, buy again if you lose a passing account
- Fees use each firm's official figures (MGC round trip: Bulenox $1.52, Tradeify $2.12, TradeDay $2.40, Topstep $1.92. FundedNext and FFN don't publish theirs, so $1.82 was used; BluSky uses third-party-sourced $1.00; The Trading Pit is assumed at $0.40 round trip + exchange fees = $1.82)
- Prices: Category A uses the prices in the table above (some, such as BluSky
30OFFand MFFUCLUB, are after coupons posted at the time of calculation); Category B uses list prices (no time-limited coupons). Instant-funding plans (Tradeify Lightning, Bulenox Fast Track) are excluded
| Skill | Win rate | Win/loss ratio | EV per trade |
|---|---|---|---|
| β0.04R | 48% | 1.0 | β0.04R |
| Zero edge | 50% | 1.0 | 0 |
| Small | 50% | 1.2 | +0.10R |
| Medium | 55% | 1.2 | +0.21R |
Result β : Zero Edge (Someone Who Neither Wins Nor Loses)
| Rank | Category | Firm / plan | Annual EV | Probability of ending positive |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | A | FTMO Futures Pro | +$4,836 | 89% |
| 2 | A | BluSky Propel (30OFF) | +$2,988 | 69% |
| 3 | B | TradeDay Quick Pay Intraday | +$2,522 | 85% |
| 4 | B | Topstep | +$2,519 | 71% |
| 5 | A | Lucid Flex (with daily loss) | +$2,152 | 68% |
| 6 | B | Bulenox Momentum (end-of-day) | +$2,047 | 58% |
| 7 | A | MyFundedFutures Builder | +$1,658 | 61% |
| 8 | A | FundedNext Futures Flex | +$1,388 | 58% |
| 9 | B | The Trading Pit Futures Prime | +$1,345 | 57% |
| 10 | B | Tradeify Growth | +$1,255 | 52% |
| 11 | A | FFN Standard MAX | β$312 | 36% |
FTMO Pro beats 2nd place by over $1,800. There are 3 reasons.
- Max loss is $3,000. Most firms are $2,000 at $50K, so at the same 0.30 lots you're less likely to fail
- You can withdraw 100% of profit, up to $5,000 per payout. FundedNext Flex and Lucid Flex cap you at 50% of profit
- The monthly fee stops once you pass. Even on a monthly plan, getting through the evaluation fast makes it equivalent to a one-time fee
TradeDay Quick Pay is cheap at $59/month, and after passing you can withdraw on any winning day, so you recover a little at a time before losing the account. That's why even a losing trader (β0.04R) came out at +$1,394 a year. But the 50% split and the $10,000 cumulative cap per account mean it doesn't grow when you win (+$8,424 at "medium" edge).
Result β‘: 'Medium' Edge (55% Win Rate, 1.2 Win/Loss Ratio)
| Rank | Category | Firm / plan | Annual EV |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | A | FTMO Futures Pro | +$26,306 |
| 2 | B | Bulenox Qualification (end-of-day) | +$25,529 |
| 3 | B | Topstep | +$24,982 |
| 4 | B | Tradeify Select Daily | +$24,218 |
| 5 | A | FFN STEADY | +$24,104 |
| 6 | A | MyFundedFutures Rapid EOD | +$24,039 |
| 7 | A | Lucid Daily | +$23,859 |
| 8 | A | FundedNext Futures Legacy | +$21,554 |
| 9 | B | The Trading Pit Futures Prime | +$21,491 |
| 10 | A | BluSky Propel (30OFF) | +$19,339 |
| 11 | B | TradeDay Fast Pass EOD | +$9,920 |
With an edge, plans with no or loose payout caps, or daily payouts, pull ahead (Bulenox Qualification has no cap from the 4th payout and a 100% split on the first $10,000; FFN STEADY, MFFU Rapid EOD, and Lucid Daily have no cap or pay daily). FTMO Pro still wins because its $5,000-per-payout cap effectively isn't a ceiling at 0.30 lots.
The bottom two are held down by where the calculation stops. BluSky is a conservative calculation that caps what one account can withdraw at $10,000 (nothing after moving to live is counted), and for TradeDay, Quick Pay has a 50% split and a $10,000 cumulative cap, and Fast Pass moves to live on the 5th payout (ending the sim account), so even with an edge it stays around $10,000 a year.
Result β’: 'Small' Edge (50% Win Rate, 1.2 Win/Loss Ratio)
| Category | Firm / plan | Annual EV |
|---|---|---|
| A | FTMO Futures Pro | +$10,141 |
| A | BluSky Propel | +$9,630 |
| B | Topstep | +$8,651 |
| B | Bulenox Momentum (end-of-day) | +$8,370 |
| B | Bulenox Qualification (end-of-day) | +$8,189 |
| B | Tradeify Select Daily | +$7,814 |
| A | MyFundedFutures Rapid EOD | +$7,723 |
| A | Lucid Daily | +$7,438 |
| A | FFN STEADY (DOUBLE50) | +$7,186 |
| B | The Trading Pit Futures Prime | +$7,078 |
| A | FundedNext Futures Flex | +$6,589 |
| B | TradeDay Quick Pay Intraday | +$4,529 |
Bulenox Qualification (end-of-day) comes to only +$432 at zero edge: Momentum is better at zero edge, Qualification once you have an edge.
Sizing Up Changes the Ranking (Category A)
If you don't standardize at 0.30 lots and instead pick whichever lot size worked best for each plan, the plans with no daily loss limit move up.
| "Medium" skill | Best lot size | Annual EV |
|---|---|---|
| Lucid Daily | 0.70 | +$57,277 |
| FFN STEADY | 0.70 | +$55,947 |
| MyFundedFutures Rapid | 0.50 | +$42,096 |
| FundedNext Futures Legacy | 0.70 | +$41,373 |
| FTMO Futures Pro | 0.30 (cap) | +$26,306 |
At 0.70 lots a single loss is $1,834 β nearly the entire $2,000 max loss. One loss ends the account, so you'll be resetting or rebuying dozens of times a year, but even after paying for that, expected value came out higher this way. Losses stop at the challenge fee and reset costs, so the baseline is to size as large as the rules allow. The rules set the cap: on plans with no daily loss limit it's the $2,000 max loss (up to 0.70 lots, where a single loss fits inside it), and on FTMO Pro the $1,000 hard daily loss caps you at 0.30 lots. FTMO's terms also prohibit "trades that couldn't be replicated with real capital (overleveraging)."
How to Choose If You're Running a Bot
| Condition | Where to go |
|---|---|
| You want to run it 24/7 on a VPS | FTMO Futures (explicitly allowed) or FundedNext Futures (allowed per the help center). In Category B, The Trading Pit (the only explicit permission) |
| You can run it on your home PC | TradeDay and Topstep are also options (both ban VPS) |
| You're not confident in your edge | FTMO Futures Pro. +$4,836 a year even at zero edge. In Category B, TradeDay Quick Pay Intraday or Topstep |
| You have an edge | FTMO Futures Pro. In Category B, Bulenox Qualification (end-of-day), Topstep, Tradeify Select Daily |
| Your EA holds through major economic releases | Avoid Lucid Daily and FFN, which treat holding within 1 minute of a release as a violation |
| You share the same bot with others | Lucid has reports of account closures citing "coordinated trading across multiple users." FTMO may also reject funded accounts for commercial EAs. TradeDay closes all accounts if multiple users are placing the same trades |
| You also use the same bot at other firms | Not allowed at Tradeify (bans using it at multiple firms) |
| You want to use a commercial EA | None of the 5 Category B firms allow it |
| You don't want to keep paying a monthly fee | One-time Lucid Flex ($90.20) or MFFU Builder ($75) |
The steps the site owner actually used to run a NinjaTrader bot on FTMO Futures are covered in How to Run Automated Trading on a Futures Prop Firm.
What's Not Included in This Calculation
- Slippage
- Payout delays at each firm, or accounts suspended at the firm's discretion (The Trading Pit's Trustpilot rating is suspended)
- Coupon expiration dates (BluSky
30OFF, FFNDOUBLE50(through September 30), MFFUCLUB, LucidVAULT) - Your share after moving to a live account (TradeDay, Bulenox, and Tradeify are cut off at the sim account, or what comes after the move isn't counted)
- Instant-funding plans
Individual Articles
Category A
- FTMO Futures Challenge Expected Value, Calculated
- FundedNext Futures Expected Value, Calculated
- MyFundedFutures Expected Value, Calculated
- Lucid Trading Expected Value, Calculated
- BluSky Expected Value, Calculated
- Funded Futures Network (FFN) Expected Value, Calculated
Category B
- Bulenox Expected Value, Calculated
- Tradeify Expected Value, Calculated
- TradeDay Expected Value, Calculated
- The Trading Pit Futures Expected Value, Calculated
- Topstep Expected Value, Calculated
Simulation scripts: scripts/sim-ftmo-futures-ev.py (FTMO), scripts/sim-futures-3firms-ev.py (FundedNext, MFFU, Lucid), scripts/sim-futures-blusky-ffn-ev.py (BluSky, FFN), scripts/sim-futures-b-ev.py (Bulenox, Tradeify, TradeDay, The Trading Pit), scripts/sim-topstep-ev.py (Topstep)
Written by
Hosono P | the prop firm strategist
I buy challenges with my own money and record everything through to the payout. Recorded payouts: Β₯6.1M in total from Fintokei, Fundora and Funded7, plus $14,297 from The5ers and RZR Funded (as of November 2026). Author of the semi-discretionary EA "ELDRA".